Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Elli Benaiah's avatar

Dear Naomi. I read your aside carefully. I value your writing enormously, even when we see the world differently. But I want to gently say that for some of us, this is not an aside.

As I write this, I am sitting in a bomb shelter with my 90-year-old mother. When ballistic missiles are aimed at where you live, geopolitics becomes immediate. It is no longer theoretical, nor symbolic, nor about personalities in Washington or Ottawa.

You may see reckless escalation. From where I sit, I also see a regime that has openly vowed for decades to wipe me off the map and has armed those who act on that vow. Those realities coexist.

I do not celebrate war. I dread it. I fear suffering - on all sides. But I also cannot reduce what is happening to the will of one “orange bully,” as if the threats we live under are imaginary or incidental.

You once wrote about shared sacred time - how the new moon depends on human eyes. We are looking at the same moon, but from very different shelters.

I continue to read you with respect. I hope we can hold complexity without flattening each other’s lived realities.

Elisabeth Luard's avatar

Yes! When in doubt, bake cake! And yr right, of course you are, it's absolutely essential to carry on talking about someone you've lost. It's full of trip-wires, naturally, but that's just how it is.

7 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?